English Corner28.04.2017
Cautious on the outlook for South Africa

JO Hambro fund manager James Syme is concerned about the direction of governance in South Africa.

We have long been concerned about the direction of governance in South Africa. ‘The management and politics’ component of our top-down country allocation process is designed not only to capture the political environment, but also the competency of the central bank, the robustness of other institutions such as the media and legal system, and also governance both at a corporate and a national level.

It is the last of these where South Africa has given us the most concern. Economic policy has tended to be fairly technocratic (although not addressing the country’s painfully low trend rate of GDP growth), the South African Reserve Bank is one of the best central banks in the emerging world, the media and law courts are independent and highly active, and corporate governance is of a high quality. It is our perception of a steady slide into corruption and nepotism in the executive that has caused us to be negative on management and politics for South Africa since 2010.

2010 saw a major, but rapidly-forgotten, scandal in South Africa. Kumba Iron Ore (then a US$20bn company) went to re-register the mineral rights of its massive Sishen iron ore mine with the Department of Mineral Resources only to discover that, hours before, a shell company had already made the registration. That shell company, it was to transpire, was 50% owned by Duduzane Zuma, the son of President Jacob Zuma. Three years of court cases subsequently led to the Constitutional Court awarding the mineral rights to Kumba, but we took these events as a seriously negative indicator of the outlook for South African equities.

That view was reinforced in December 2015, when a wellrespected finance minister was suddenly replaced by unknown MP David van Rooyen. South African financial markets reacted very badly to the news, leading to the appointment of a third finance minister in five days: Pravin Gordhan. This showed both the vulnerability of South African markets to political events and also a lack of understanding of markets at the highest level in South Africa.

Since then, South Africa’s vulnerability has only increased. Sovereign debt is rated at just above non-investment grade level, and all three major ratings agencies have stressed the importance of fiscal orthodoxy in maintaining those ratings.

The sacking of Mr. Gordhan this month would seem to have accelerated market awareness of political risk in South Africa. The full impact on bond and currency markets may take some time to come out, but risks remain elevated as other investors come round to our view. With real GDP growth having averaged an annual 1.6% over the last ten years, it is not as though the growth story is compelling. We remain neutrally-weighted in South Africa, but hold a company that achieves almost all its economic value from outside South Africa. There is an outside chance that the current crisis will lead to President Zuma’s removal, which might open up the opportunity for desperately-needed economic reforms, but until then we remain cautious on the outlook for the South African economy and domestically-focused stocks. 

Autor: jod

Weitere Meldungen

Switzerland is Average for Fund Investors

19.10.2017 - Morningstar's fifth Global Fund Investor Experience (GFIE) study shows that Switzerland retains an overall grade of Average, with a number of improvements made since the last survey.  Mehr...

Believe the Hype?

18.10.2017 - Grand visions of China’s One Belt One Road (OBOR) infrastructure project continue to make headlines but for now portfolio manager Naomi Waistell, of Newton’s emerging and Asian equity team, is curbing her enthusiasm.  Mehr...

Investing in EM When Interest Rates Rise

12.10.2017 - Emerging markets have seen a pickup in flows so far this year, yet a common concern remains – can they avoid taper tantrum 2.0.? Colm McDonagh, Insight (BNY Mellon), gives an outlook.  Mehr...

Northern Trust becomes Switzerland's largest Fund Administrator

04.10.2017 - Northern Trust announced the closing of its acquisition of UBS Asset Management's fund administration servicing units in Luxembourg and Switzerland.  Mehr...

Julius Baer Group places USD-denominated Additional Tier 1 bond

06.09.2017 - Julius Baer Group has placed perpetual non-cumulative high-trigger Additional Tier 1 (AT1) securities in a debut USD 300 million transaction with institutional and qualified private banking investors in Asia and Europe. The transaction helps to optimise Julius Baer Group’s capital structure.  Mehr...


China verbietet den Handel von Kryptowährungen und der Bitcoinkurs sinkt zwischenzeitlich um 30%. Haben Bitcoins, Ethereum etc. trotzdem eine Zukunft?




Das Ende der Globalisierung?

24.10.2017 16:30 | Zürich
Fund Experts Forum

10. Schweizer Leadership Pensions Forum 2017

25.10.2017 08:30 | Zürich
Financial Times

10. Schweizer Leadership Pensions Forum 2017

25.10.2017 08:30 | Zürich
Financial Times

Bond Investments: Was verheisst die Zinssituation?

31.10.2017 18:30 | Zürich
Friends of Funds

Opportunities 2018: Breaking New Ground

01.11.2017 08:15 | Zürich
Finanz und Wirtschaft Forum
zu allen Events

Indizes Schweiz

In Zusammenarbeit mit  morningstar.ch


Die Marktkurse werden Ihnen von Investing.com Deutschland zur Verfügung gestellt.